TO THINK ABOUT
What kinds of animals live longer and shorter in captivity than in the wild? Why?
Fish otoliths, fish scales, tree rings and coral growth bands are used to tell the age of living things. What time-range does each cover?
Can you tell the age at which a mummy died?
When can growth rings be better at telling age than tooth wear or wrinkling?
How are various materials used to tell the history of the Earth's climate in the distant past, beyond the lifespan of animals that live now?
How do we know the age of a fish? We know the lifespan of fishes we've kept in captivity, but accurate lifespans of wild fishes are more difficult to determine.
Like trees, certain parts of fishes grow annual rings that can be counted to determine age - the bones in the ears, scales and vertebra in some sharks.
The method is straightforward, but forensic specialists must recognize exceptions, when one ring doesn't correspond to one year. Many exceptions occur for a variety of complex factors. The preliminary investigation of confirming the growth rate of rings for a particular species of fish is called validation. Like forensic evidence that sets a timeline for a crime - such as the development of insects found on homicide victims - if the assumptions about rate of development are incorrect whether otolith, scale, vertebra or blow fly, the timeline is also incorrect.
Zoom
Striped Bass Morone saxatilis.
Annual growth rings on a fish scale.
Photographer - John Boardman, Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries.
To learn more:
How many fish can be safely caught each year without causing unrecoverable declines in population? It depends on the reproductive rate of particular fishes, and total numbers of existing fish (the stock). Part of "fisheries management" is determining how many are safe to catch and alloting the safe catch to different groups of people.
Fisheries managers need to know the reproductive ages of fishes and their lifespan. Fishes that occur in greater numbers, reproduce at a younger age and have more young are more likely to withstand higher rates of fishing than ones that are few, reproduce later in life and produce few young like many sharks. The Bull Shark reaches reproductive age between 10-18 years of age, has a gestation period of 10-11 months and 1-13 pups at a time. Although relatively few survive, numerous Atlantic Herring lay 20-200 thousand eggs at a time at 3-4 years of age.
The slower the rate of reproduction, the smaller the safe catch. Fishes such as the Orange Roughy have been estimated to live more than a century. As a graduate student, Krista Baker of Memorial University in Newfoundland, Canada put it this way - when you dine on orange roughy, "you could be eating a fish that was born when Lincoln was president." Although the very top age estimates of 150 years are debated, the Orange Roughy is clearly a long-lived fish. The Orange Roughy like other fishes that suddenly appeared in grocery stores has become increasingly scarce today.
Otoliths (ear bones)
Zoom
Otolith (ear bone or earstone) of Common Snook (Centropomus undecimalis).
Image courtesy Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission.
Fish have several earstones or otoliths in their heads.
Scales
Zoom
Irridescent fish scale.
Photographer - Chana Nudelman-Faust,
image courtesy Avital Levy-Lior [29].
Shark vertebrae